PDF Ebook What Is Wrong with Jung?, by Don Mcgowan
For everybody, if you intend to start accompanying others to review a book, this What Is Wrong With Jung?, By Don Mcgowan is much advised. As well as you should get the book What Is Wrong With Jung?, By Don Mcgowan below, in the link download that we offer. Why should be below? If you desire various other type of publications, you will certainly always locate them and also What Is Wrong With Jung?, By Don Mcgowan Economics, national politics, social, scientific researches, religions, Fictions, and a lot more books are provided. These available books remain in the soft files.
What Is Wrong with Jung?, by Don Mcgowan
PDF Ebook What Is Wrong with Jung?, by Don Mcgowan
Book enthusiasts, when you need a new book to read, locate guide What Is Wrong With Jung?, By Don Mcgowan right here. Never worry not to discover just what you need. Is the What Is Wrong With Jung?, By Don Mcgowan your needed book currently? That's true; you are actually a good visitor. This is an ideal book What Is Wrong With Jung?, By Don Mcgowan that originates from wonderful writer to show you. The book What Is Wrong With Jung?, By Don Mcgowan supplies the best experience and also lesson to take, not just take, yet likewise learn.
Getting the books What Is Wrong With Jung?, By Don Mcgowan now is not kind of hard method. You could not just choosing publication shop or library or borrowing from your friends to review them. This is an extremely basic method to exactly obtain the publication by online. This on the internet e-book What Is Wrong With Jung?, By Don Mcgowan could be one of the alternatives to accompany you when having downtime. It will not lose your time. Believe me, the publication will certainly reveal you brand-new thing to review. Just spend little time to open this online book What Is Wrong With Jung?, By Don Mcgowan as well as read them wherever you are now.
Sooner you get the publication What Is Wrong With Jung?, By Don Mcgowan, faster you can appreciate reading the book. It will certainly be your turn to maintain downloading the publication What Is Wrong With Jung?, By Don Mcgowan in provided link. By doing this, you can really making a decision that is offered to obtain your very own e-book on the internet. Right here, be the first to get the book qualified What Is Wrong With Jung?, By Don Mcgowan as well as be the very first to know exactly how the writer indicates the message as well as understanding for you.
It will believe when you are going to choose this publication. This motivating What Is Wrong With Jung?, By Don Mcgowan publication could be reviewed entirely in specific time relying on exactly how usually you open as well as review them. One to remember is that every book has their very own manufacturing to get by each reader. So, be the excellent visitor as well as be a better person after reviewing this book What Is Wrong With Jung?, By Don Mcgowan
In this detailed and systematic critique of the theories of psychologist Carl G. Jung (1875-1961), Don McGowan exposes the many flaws in Jungian analysis and methodology. Beginning with Jung's interpretation of religion and his attempts to draw parallels between mythology and his patients' dreams, McGowan finds a consistent lack of rigor, a highly selective use of evidence, and a tendency toward broad generalization, which ignores important cultural distinctions.
Jung's popular theory of the collective unconscious is especially criticized as an example of over-interpretation and a failure to examine the diversity of cultural evidence. His proposed archetypes, derived from a narrow and rather biased study of Indo-European cultures, may reflect nothing more than patterns of cultural conditioning, argues McGowan, and not some universal substructure of the human mind, as Jung suggests.
In Jung's ideas about the "blond beast" and other "innate" characteristics of various races, McGowan detects disturbing echoes of Alfred Rosenberg, the German Nazi Party's chief ideologist; and his attitude toward women, by today's standards, is decidedly sexist - all of which makes his continuing popularity in the politically correct 1990's difficult to understand.
Despite these fundamental problems in Jungian analysis, McGowan points out that some of Jung's ideas have enduring scientific value. Jung's contrasting categories of extraversion and introversion, and his thinking, feeling, sensing, and intuiting personality types are based on empirical observations.
What Is Wrong With Jung? is the only critique of Jung's work that does not attempt to promote another school of psychological analysis in place of the Jungian approach. McGowan's objective, thorough, and very readable presentation will be of interest to critics and advocates of Jung alike.
- Sales Rank: #2550430 in Books
- Brand: Brand: Prometheus Books
- Published on: 1994-02-01
- Released on: 1994-02-01
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.30" h x .91" w x 6.30" l, 1.07 pounds
- Binding: Hardcover
- 219 pages
- Used Book in Good Condition
From the Back Cover
In this detailed and systematic critique of the theories of psychologist Carl G. Jung (1875-1961), Don McGowan exposes the many flaws in Jungian analysis and methodology. Beginning with Jung's interpretation of religion and his attempts to draw parallels between mythology and his patients' dreams, McGowan finds a consistent lack of rigor, a highly selective use of evidence, and a tendency toward broad generalization, which ignores important cultural distinctions. Jung's popular theory of the collective unconscious is especially criticized as an example of overinterpretation and a failure to examine the diversity of cultural evidence. His proposed archetypes, which are derived from a narrow and rather biased study of Indo-European cultures, may reflect nothing more than patterns of cultural conditioning, argues McGowan, and not some universal substructure of the human mind, as Jung suggests. In Jung's ideas about the "blond beast" and other "innate" characteristics of various races, McGowan detects disturbing echoes of Alfred Rosenberg, the German Nazi Party's chief ideologist; and his attitude toward women, by today's standards, is decidedly sexist - all of which makes his continuing popularity in the politically correct 1990s difficult to understand. Despite these fundamental problems in Jungian analysis, McGowan points out that some of Jung's ideas, particularly his contributions to personality theory, have enduring scientific value. Jung's contrasting categories of extraversion and introversion, and his thinking, feeling, sensing, and intuiting personality types are based on empirical observations. Unlike so much of Jungian theory, his personality theory is testable and is widelyused by modern psychologists today. What Is Wrong with Jung is the only critique of Jung's work that does not attempt to promote another school of psychological analysis in place of the Jungian approach. McGowan's objective, thorough, and very readable presentation will be of interest to critics and advocates of Jung alike.
Most helpful customer reviews
5 of 17 people found the following review helpful.
Intellectual muscle as a means of survival
By Mark J. Feldman
Don McGowan is becoming the eminence grise of Intellectual Muscle movement while remaining its enfant terrible -still capable of confounding his audience with new twists and turns in his work.
McGowan's work has always been analytical, but in recent years his work morphed from the analysis of Jung toward the psychological, specifically Freudian, kind. For some time now, he has recycled the texts of Jung into muscular pieces that resemble sculpted post modern works that often boggle the mind and eye.
The strength of McGowan's work resides in his ability to compress radical and imense ideas into puny pieces of magma, one that the viewer wants to hold, yet cannot due to weight and temperature considerations.
Against all odds, McGowan's journey concludes with seemingly random thoughts twisted and turned back to which it began, with only an elbow to the guy who wrote the bad review in '01.
13 of 15 people found the following review helpful.
Nothing Is Wrong
By Just Another Reader
I have read most of Jung's works, as well as those of his followers. I find a great amount of truth in his works, but I also think his work suffers a similar fate as that of people like Einstein and Darwin; no theory stands unchallenged forever. As a trailblazer Jung opened doors of inquiry. As an imperfect human being he made some mistakes. Those mistakes are being critiqued and analyzed by people with 100 years of learning on Jung. So parts of his work might be revised, others discarded, and totally new parts added. People who pick on Jung for being ethnocentric or chauvanistic fail to account for the time and culture he lived in (again 100 years of learning). I think this book has great value, because it questions Jung's theories, and that's scientific. But let's not go overboard and "tar and feather" the man. He truly was a pioneer in his field.
11 of 15 people found the following review helpful.
The Jungian Cult ?
By zuzan
I am still reading the book. However, it was the very title that drew my interest and why I sought out this book to read. I hope the author shares my need to seek answers to what for me is a painful question, "What Is Wrong With Jung". Watching my once honorable (former) husband's moral compass morph to zero while on his really long path to individuation and punctuated with Jungian jargon has been devastating. His Jungian therapist's PhD thesis was on the evolution of the male consciousness by way of a fairy tale. During the first 10 years and counting (15) of my husband's very expensive therapy, the Jungian therapist (as plaintiff) divorced twice, and advised my husband do the same. I have read dozens and dozens of books and articles on Jung and Jungian theory and therapy, attempting to understand the attributions to dreams, fantasies, archetypes, entitlement, first adulthood, second adulthood, introvert, extrovert, mythology, alchemy, the collective unconscious, astrology, art, and visions and more. I am hoping this book might, as much as it is possible, pull it all together for me. As of this writing, when I hear the words Jung or Jungian, I think svengali. I think cult.
(Four stars as I have not yet finished the book).
What Is Wrong with Jung?, by Don Mcgowan PDF
What Is Wrong with Jung?, by Don Mcgowan EPub
What Is Wrong with Jung?, by Don Mcgowan Doc
What Is Wrong with Jung?, by Don Mcgowan iBooks
What Is Wrong with Jung?, by Don Mcgowan rtf
What Is Wrong with Jung?, by Don Mcgowan Mobipocket
What Is Wrong with Jung?, by Don Mcgowan Kindle
No comments:
Post a Comment